Pick 24 Homemade Cookies Tap on image to zoom
Pick 24 Homemade Cookies
Available to purchase on full site only.


by PowerReviews
Harry & DavidPick 24 Homemade Cookies

(based on 2 reviews)

Ratings Distribution

  • 5 Stars



  • 4 Stars



  • 3 Stars



  • 2 Stars



  • 1 Stars



Reviewed by 2 customers

Sort by

Displaying reviews 1-2

Back to top

(34 of 36 customers found this review helpful)


Good for a group or family

By Tabster

from Coastal Oregon

See all my reviews


  • Attractive
  • Good variety


  • Bit expensive for cookies
  • Not a good value

Best Uses

  • Birthday Gift
  • Corporate Gift

Comments about Harry & David Pick 24 Homemade Cookies:

Recipient liked that cookies were individually wrapped. They were nice looking and tasty. They were shared with folks living in a small retirement home, so I chose only cookies with no nuts - there was still plenty of variety and a colorful appearance.

Due to previous problems with staff and recipient not being able to comprehend the complex exterior computer labels and message, I paid 4 bucks for a card. That is a ridiculous price for a card H&D does not even hand-write. A card should be an inclusive part of any H&D gift, that is part of the whole package. H&D prices are high and so is shipping. $4 to send a greeing that should be included is my only pet peeve with this service.

Comment on this review

(18 of 20 customers found this review helpful)


Expensive, but okay

By Nursie

from Pittsburgh, PA

Verified Reviewer


  • Good variety
  • Great presentation
  • Individually wrapped
  • Quality brand name food


  • A little expensive

Best Uses

  • Any occasion
  • Birthday Gift
  • Christmas Gift
  • Congratulations
  • Corporate Gift
  • Sympathy Basket
  • Thank you/Appreciation Gift

Comments about Harry & David Pick 24 Homemade Cookies:

I hated to only give 3 stars (because it was a matter of personal taste), but I kind of had to; because I had ordered cookies that I KNEW that I liked. If they weren't so expensive, they would have gotten 5 stars. After that, they would have gotten 4 stars, except I didn't care much for them. I LOVE peanut butter cookies, and I LOVE chocolate frosting, and I LOVE peanut butter cookies wih chocolate frosting! That is why I ordered EIGHTEEN of them. They didn't taste BAD, they just weren't as good as I expected. The double chocolate (I ordered two), I didn't like AT ALL (which surprised me). The Macademia (two) was OKAY. The Snickerdoodle (two) (now THIS one surprised me, because of the four different cookies I ordered, snickerdoodle was my LEAST favourite!) was GOOD! Just be aware, that everyone has their own idea of what a "good recipe" is. Now, that all said...the PACKAGING was EXEMPLARY! The box was packed like there was a GLASS product inside! KUDOS for PACKAGING! The "gift box" inside was very attractive and also well packed with "grass" (although personally I don't like "grass"...too messy) and was arranged VERY nicely. The cookies are INDIVIDUALLY wrapped which is a HUMONGOUS plus!!! It's a little too expensive if you are buying it for yourself; but even after all I said above; it STILL makes a GREAT gift!

Comment on this review

Displaying reviews 1-2

Back to top

Read Reviews Write a Review
Questions & Answers

Do you have questions about this product?

get answers from real customers and in-house experts with AnswerBox.

1 Question | 1 Answer
Displaying question 1
  • Q:

    Can this "pick your own" include sugar-free cookies?
    Asked on 7/19/2013 by JQ from Denver

    1 answer

    • Staff Reviewer


      JQ, unfortunately at this time we do not offer sugar free cookies as a selection in our Pick 24 Homemade Cookies. We do offer offer sugar free cookies though! Please click here to see our Mt. Baker Sugar Free Cookie Gift Tower: http://www.harryanddavid.com/h/26651?sliSearch=sugar%20free

      Answered on 7/19/2013 by Customer Care from Medford, OR
Displaying question 1

Do you have a question about this product? 

Item  W-752G
$19.95$14.9525% OFF
4 (49)
Item  W-26581G
$29.95$24.9516% OFF
4.5 (48)